Loading...
Loading...
AI SOC vs SOAR comes down to who writes the response. SOAR runs steps your team scripted in advance. An AI SOC Agent investigates each SIEM alert from the evidence and proposes a response for analysts to approve. AI SOC wins on alert triage; SOAR still wins on fixed, audited steps like disabling an account.
CrowdStrike's 2026 Global Threat Report puts the average eCrime breakout time at 29 minutes, and 82% of the detections it logged in 2025 were malware-free, with no known-bad file for a playbook to match. Every alert type your playbooks don't cover waits in a queue for a person while that clock runs.
The difference between AI SOC and SOAR is who does the thinking. Security orchestration, automation, and response (SOAR) runs playbooks your engineers write. If an alert matches condition X, the playbook queries the EDR, enriches the alert with threat intelligence, opens a ticket, and isolates the host. When the alert pattern changes, someone has to rewrite it.
An AI SOC Agent starts from the alert. It pulls context through integrations with your SIEM, EDR, identity, cloud, and ticketing tools, forms a hypothesis about what happened, tests it against the evidence, and reaches a verdict with its reasoning attached. It does that for alert types nobody scripted, too.
Vendor decks blur four terms. SOAR automation is the playbook engine on its own. SOAR AI adds LLM features to that engine (alert summaries, query generation, AI that drafts playbooks), and AI SOAR is largely the same engine sold under an AI-first name such as agentic SOAR or next-gen SOAR. In most of these products, the response still comes from playbooks or plans someone on your side authored. An AI SOC, sometimes called an agentic SOC, investigates from context and proposes the response itself.
A SOAR playbook still wins when a response has to run the same way every time and someone has to be able to prove it did. Disabling an account under change control, blocking a known-bad malware hash, and sending a regulated notification are deterministic actions. A script fits them exactly.
Playbooks are also cheap to trust.
Once written, a playbook for a high-volume, unchanging alert runs in seconds and gives auditors the same record every time.
The best independent evidence on SOAR cuts both ways. Researchers at Oak Ridge National Laboratory ran the first hands-on user study of SOAR tools, with 24 participants (21 of them analysts from U.S. Navy SOCs) working investigations in a cyber range on six commercial SOAR products (Bridges et al., Computers & Security, 2023). The tools made investigations faster and cut context switching, but the tickets participants wrote tended to be less complete and less correct. Senior analysts worried about over-automation and preferred the tools that balanced automation with helping them make the decision.
That last finding applies to AI SOC tools too. An agent that reaches a confident verdict on a novel alert can still be wrong, and speed makes a wrong verdict travel further. So ask any AI SOC vendor to show you its reasoning, and let your team decide which actions the Agent can take alone.
Yes, for triage. Triage is the step between "the SIEM fired" and "we know what this is," and it's where playbooks run out. The alerts that fill a queue rarely match a playbook cleanly, so they wait for a person, and alert fatigue sets in. Three kinds a playbook handles badly:
SOAR stalls or escalates each of these to a person, because it can only react to what its author anticipated. Teams respond by writing more playbooks, and the library keeps growing. In the SOAR migrations we run, we typically see teams automating around 25% of their alert volume before they switch.
An AI SOC Agent works these the way a senior analyst would. It checks who the user is, what the vendor relationship looks like, and whether a test is scheduled, then decides. Simbian's AI SOC Agent takes every threat from detection to response in under 4 minutes on average. 95% of the responses it proposes are approved by the customer's own analysts. Their call, not ours.
At Bottomline Technologies, alert coverage went from about 30% to approaching 100%, with 80% of the investigation done before an analyst opens the case.
Not yet. SOAR AI adds agents and LLM features to a playbook platform, and in most products the response still comes from a playbook, plan, or prompt your team configures. An AI SOC Agent removes that authoring step. It investigates each alert from context and proposes the response.
The gap is narrower than it was a year ago, and any comparison that still calls the vendors' AI a bolt-on is out of date.
When an analyst disagrees with a verdict in Simbian, they change it and leave a comment, and that correction becomes a context update request. Nothing changes until a person approves it, and after that it shapes every matching investigation. That loop is what Simbian calls Self-Improving Defense.
In one customer's environment, the EDR kept classifying a signed Admin By Request component as process hollowing, and each of those alerts sent the Agent hunting across the whole host before it concluded the behavior was legitimate. The Agent spotted the pattern across investigations and drafted a scenario Skill: validate the signed component, confirm the managed-endpoint workflow, check child processes for malicious follow-on, and stop.
A person approved it.
On matching alerts since, the Agent reads the alert's process chain and what the component started rather than the whole host, cites the Skill every time, and verdict quality has held. That result covers one tenant and one alert type, after a single approved improvement. Every matching alert so far has been legitimate, so it shows benign cases closing with less work. It can't show how the Skill handles a real attack: a DLL side-loaded into the signed component could pass the first check, which is why the follow-on check carries the weight.
When triage shows a detection rule is noisy, the AI Detection Engineering Agent proposes the change, and a human approves it. It works from the same Context Lake™ as the AI SOC Agent and the AI Pentest Agent.
SIEM vs SOAR vs AI SOC is a question about three layers of the SOC stack, and only one pair overlaps. A security information and event management (SIEM) platform (Splunk, Microsoft Sentinel, Google Security Operations, Elastic, IBM QRadar) collects and stores telemetry, correlates events, fires detection rules in real time, and remains your system of record for compliance reporting.
SOAR sits beside the SIEM. It runs the incident response you designed. An AI SOC sits at the same layer as SOAR, reads alerts from the SIEM and your other tools, investigates each one, and proposes the response for your analysts to approve.
The SIEM stays either way. You're choosing between SOAR and an AI SOC for the work after detection. Many teams keep a handful of playbooks for containment steps and let the Agent take triage and investigation.
You replace SOAR without rewriting playbooks by giving the Agent what the playbooks were for. Your runbooks and playbooks go in as plain-language context, and the AI SOC Agent builds its own Skill from them. Skills are versioned, regression-tested, and owned by your team.
A playbook-to-playbook conversion keeps the maintenance cost you were trying to leave. Simbian's SOAR alternative starts from your context. None of it is binding. Give the Agent your playbook history up front, or give it nothing at all and let it learn your environment from the alerts it works. The Simbian vs SOAR comparison lays out the differences row by row.
The move itself is gradual:
Stop writing new playbooks. Every new playbook is one more thing to migrate later. Check each new use case against what the Agent already handles.
Run both on one alert category. Pick a high-volume type such as phishing and run SOAR and the AI SOC Agent side by side for two to four weeks. Compare analyst approval rate, mean time to respond, false positives, and analyst hours.
Retire playbooks as the Agent proves coverage. Track which playbooks the Agent has made redundant and retire them from maintenance one at a time. Keep the ones that run fixed, audited steps, such as disabling an account.
Decide at renewal. Make the SOAR replacement decision with your own numbers from the first three steps.
SOAR wins on deterministic, audited steps, and an AI SOC Agent wins on novel alerts and triage coverage. The table adds SOAR AI as a third column and compares all three on the criteria that decide a SIEM alert triage purchase.
| SOAR | SOAR AI / AI SOAR | AI SOC Agent | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who writes the response | Your engineers, per playbook | Your team configures plans; AI drafts and triages | The Agent proposes; your analysts approve |
| Novel SIEM alerts | Stalls or escalates | Investigates within vendor limits; responds from a plan your team wrote | Investigates from context |
| Triage coverage | Grows with playbook count | Capped by vendor limits | Not tied to playbook count |
| Maintenance | Playbook upkeep and case management | Playbook upkeep, faster authoring | Approving proposed context updates |
| Learns from analyst decisions | No | Depends on the product; some claim to learn from past cases | Corrections become approved context |
| Audit trail | Playbook run logs | Run logs plus AI summaries | Reasoning and evidence for every verdict |
| Time to first value | After the first playbooks are built and tested | Varies; AI triage can start early, responses still need plans | From the first alerts it investigates |
| Best fit | Fixed, audited response steps | SOAR shops adding AI to what they have | Triage and investigation at volume |
Q: Is SOAR dead? No, but its job is shrinking. Gartner's 2024 Hype Cycle for Security Operations marked SOAR "obsolete before plateau." Gartner analyst Eric Ahlm told Dark Reading that other products are absorbing its parts and automation is becoming an expected feature. SOAR keeps the jobs it does best: deterministic, audited response steps that must run the same way every time. Triage and investigation are moving out of it.
Q: Do you still need SOAR if you have an AI SOC Agent? Usually not for triage and investigation, and sometimes yes for a small set of containment steps your auditors want scripted. Keep those as playbooks, and point the AI SOC Agent at the alerts no playbook was written for. Your SIEM stays in place either way.
Q: Is AI SOAR the same as an AI SOC? No. AI SOAR is a SOAR platform with AI added, so in most products the response still comes from playbooks or plans your team configures. An AI SOC investigates each alert from the context around it and proposes the response, so a new alert type doesn't wait for someone to script it.
Q: What happens to existing SOAR playbooks when you switch? They turn into context for the Agent. Simbian's AI SOC Agent reads your runbooks and playbooks in plain language and builds its own Skills from them, so the knowledge in them carries over without a playbook-to-playbook conversion. The playbooks you keep for fixed steps can stay in SOAR.
Q: What are the challenges in replacing a SOAR system? The hard parts are trusting verdicts nobody scripted, fitting a new tool into a mature stack, and keeping an audit trail your regulators accept. Start with one alert category and require reasoning and evidence on every verdict. Keep scripted playbooks for the containment steps your auditors want fixed.
Q: Does an AI SOC replace my SIEM? No. The SIEM stays your system of record for telemetry and detection rules, and the AI SOC sits after it. The AI SOC Agent reads alerts from your SIEM and queries it during each investigation, so your logs stay where they are and your detection rules keep firing as before.
Choose a SOAR alternative by how it handles the alerts your playbooks miss. The one that's easiest to adopt reads the alerts your SIEM already fires, shows the evidence behind every verdict, and lets your team decide which actions it can take alone. Nothing gets rebuilt first.
The SOAR alternatives on offer map to the table's last two columns: SOAR AI on the engine you already run, or an AI SOC Agent. In a demo, four checks separate them:
Then settle AI SOC vs SOAR on your own alerts, since a demo only shows the alerts a vendor picked. The AI SOC Buyer's Scorecard turns these checks into a scoring sheet you can take into each demo. Run the side-by-side from step two before your renewal date.